Home Current News News Archive Shop/Advertise Ridecamp Classified Events Learn/AERC
Endurance.Net Home Ridecamp Archives
ridecamp@endurance.net
[Archives Index]   [Date Index]   [Thread Index]   [Author Index]   [Subject Index]

Re: [RC] New Poll up - Jim Holland

Joe Long wrote:


For one thing, I was on the Board from 1980 to 1994, and worked hard
for better equine safety.  I was one of those who worked hard to adopt
"fit to continue" as a finishing criteria.  Do you know there were
individuals who argued that if a horse crossed the finish line first,
then dropped dead ten feet past it, the rider was still the winner of
the ride and should get his trophies, points and miles?

Doesn't suprise me...the attitude on the Board hasn't changed much.
Probably some of the same people still there....


Hell, maybe I'll write a book...isn't that what I'm supposed to do?

I can't say what you're supposed to do.  I do not believe what I've
seen you doing is contributing to improving equine safety.

Everybody is entitled to their opinion.



Many of us have been doing "something" for years.  Were you around in
the "crash and burn" days before vet gates, before CRI's and taking
temperatures, when a horse had an hour to reach a pulse rate of 72,
and there was no post-finish requirement at all?

I crewed a lot in the latter part of that era....I well remember the
stories. Not much there to be proud of.....from the horse's standpoint.

...
When I was competing in the SE and working with rides and the SERA we
had periods of several years without a fatality, a fact I am quite
proud of.  But there were tragic fatalities in some years, including
multiple deaths in a single year.  Short-term statistics on
low-frequency events don't really mean very much.  And a decade is
short-term in this issue, and ten is small, yes.

7 years is short term? Ten is small? Now, IMHO, THAT is bullshit!

Your saying that just shows that you don't understand statistics.  I'm
a poker player and I've seen the working of probability and statistics
up close and personal.  Yes, seven years is short-term in an issue
like this.  You have been saying the deaths are increasing, when they
have been about ten in each of the last two years.  I don't have the
statistics to know if that is an increase, but at any rate it would
take more than a few years of continuing increases to know that it was
really a trend.  Finally, ten in the entire U.S., given the number of
rides and riders, is not a large number.  Even one is more than we
want, but ten does not mean the sky is falling.

I, too, play poker...what do you think we do during all those "stand by
and wait" hours in the Corps? IMHO, the reason we don't have statistics
is because AERC has tried sweep those statistics under the rug over the
years. 

You know, insurance companies have good statisticians, and they don't
like to lose money.  Yet they happily insure endurance horses.  Tell
you something?

Yeah...they don't know the risk!
...
There has been far too much bombast, smoke, arm-waving, mud-slinging,
chest-beating and hypocrisy spewn out on this list on this issue for
too long, most of it from about three people.  You aren't helping, and
if you really want to help, shut the hell up and try to learn
something from those who've actually been working with the problem for
a while.

Over the last couple of years, I think most people on Ridecamp would
agree that I have been "working on the problem for a while". And who
might those people you are referring to be?

If the shoe fits ... although Howard was who I had most in mind.

I wasn't referring to me...or Howard....I was referring to your
statement that I might "learn something from those who've actually been
working with the problem for while". Obvious you consider yourself in
that list, but I still contend progress has been to slow.

....and were I not a
gentleman and a Marine, I might have more to say on your suggestion.

I don't expect you to take it.  You are on a Holy Mission, and you
believe you Know More and Care More than the rest of us.  At least
that's how you come off.

Stay tuned, Joe...Film at 11:00....

Jim, Sun of Dimanche+, and Mahada Magic


=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Ridecamp is a service of Endurance Net, http://www.endurance.net.
Information, Policy, Disclaimer: http://www.endurance.net/Ridecamp
Subscribe/Unsubscribe http://www.endurance.net/ridecamp/logon.asp

Ride Long and Ride Safe!!

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=


Replies
Re: [RC] New Poll up, Joe Long
Re: [RC] New Poll up, Jim Holland
Re: [RC] New Poll up, Joe Long
Re: [RC] New Poll up, Jim Holland
Re: [RC] New Poll up, Joe Long