Home Current News News Archive Shop/Advertise Ridecamp Classified Events Learn/AERC
Endurance.Net Home Ridecamp Archives
ridecamp@endurance.net
[Archives Index]   [Date Index]   [Thread Index]   [Author Index]   [Subject Index]

[RC] Fw: What will they think of next - Jeannie Gillen


----- Original Message -----
From: "Elin Motherhead" <doublemelin@xxxxxxxxxxx>
To: "Ginger VonAchen" <GVonAchen@xxxxxxxxx>; "Dan and Cheryl Searer"
<DLSearer@xxxxxx>; "Jeannie Gillen" <Jeanniegillen@xxxxxxxxxxxxx>; "Dave
Drefchinski" <davesbarn@xxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Wednesday, January 07, 2004 1:26 AM
Subject: What will they think of next


POOP SCOOPING MANURE - "hay goes in - hay goes out"


I'm passing this on:

Dear Horse Lovers,

Any horse owner or enthusiast would be aghast to learn about the
current movement against equestrians in Newport Beach, CA. The
enforcement of an ordinance requiring horse riders to PICK UP AFTER
THEIR HORSES on the trail illustrates the ignorance of non-equestrians
towards the animals that we love (See the article below). This sounds
like a joke, but it isn't. In crowded Southern California, the rights
of horse owners are quickly being eroded. We are constantly fighting
to ensure that our trails are not demolished for golf courses, that
our horse properties are not rezoned to bar horses, and NOW THIS!!!!

HELP STOP THE MADNESS! PLEASE SEND THIS TO THE HORSE LOVERS YOU KNOW
AND URGE THEM TO CONTACT THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH.

CITY MANAGER HOMER BLUDAU
EMAIL: hbludau@xxxx
PHONE: 949-644-3000

ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER DAVID KIFF
PHONE: 949-644-3002


LOS ANGELES TIMES ARTICLE, JANUARY 2, 2004

Cleanup Rule Is a Bur Under Their Saddle
 Enforcing Newport Beach's scooper law pits residents, who recoil at
the mess, against equestrians, who deny the manure is a hazard.

By David Haldane, Times Staff Writer, Los Angeles Times, January 2,
2004

Santa Ana Heights is a horse lover's dream.

Several miles of bridle trails meander through idyllic terrain. Most
of the houses sit on lots large enough to accommodate animals and
corrals.

Recently, however, the dream has been marred by an argument over
biological realities. New signs posted on the trails warn of $100 to
$500 fines for owners whose horses leave a mess. And, adding insult to
injury, several houses along sidewalks and trails now sport shovels
with cans.

"It's just a good-neighbor issue," says Barbara Venezia, a
non-equestrian resident of one of those houses and organizer of what
she calls the "adopt-a-poop-can" campaign. "The bottom line is: If
you've got an animal, take care of it."

Local equestrians say they certainly don't mind taking care of their
animals. But some are incensed by a municipal ordinance that treats
them exactly as it does dog owners who don't clean up after their pets
on the street. And in what may be the first case of its kind anywhere,
horse people say they plan to show up en masse at a city hearing later
this month to protest the law.

"We're challenging not only the enforcement of the code, but the code
itself," said Tom Anderson, president of the Orange County Equestrian
Coalition, which recently paid the fine of a woman cited for allegedly
leaving her horse's manure on a sidewalk. "We've always believed this
to be a nonissue. It shows a complete lack of understanding by urban
people about what it means to have a horse as a pet."

Countered David Kiff, an assistant city manager in charge of enforcing
the ordinance: "I can't just look the other way with horses."

The conflict has recent roots. For years, East Santa Ana Heights - a
194-acre area made up of about 400 homes just northeast of Newport
Beach - was an unincorporated Orange County island zoned for
equestrian use. Last July, in keeping with the county's efforts to rid
itself of unincorporated areas, it was annexed by Newport Beach.

As a result, according to Kiff, "the community is subject to all of
our ordinances," including the one requiring pet owners to clean up
after their pets. Though the law is aimed primarily at dog owners, he
says, "it would apply to any animal, including a horse."

The city posted the "no manure" signs almost immediately. Then it
shelled out $89 for Venezia's cans.

But things really heated up a few weeks ago when Cheryl Skidmore, a
horse owner who lives in Costa Mesa but frequently rides in Santa Ana
Heights, was cited and fined for allegedly leaving a mess.

"I did clean it up," she said later, "but [the officer] said it wasn't
cleaned up to his satisfaction."

City officials argue that the horse manure is an environmental hazard
that can seep into storm drains, ending up in Newport Bay. "There are
certain parts of the bay and many tributaries that are way above state
standards" for fecal bacteria, Kiff said.

The city, he said, is under court order to keep those levels low.

Equestrians, on the other hand, maintain that because horses are
herbivores, their waste is benign. "Hay goes in, hay comes out," says
Jayne Jones, a member of Back Bay Equestrians, a local riding group.
"You can use horse manure for compost - a lot of people put it in
their gardens. It's practically the same stuff you can buy at Home
Depot - it's actually good for the environment."

Besides, they argue, cleaning up horse droppings can be dangerous for
riders. "There's a considerable difference," Anderson said, "between
picking up your dog's droppings in a plastic bag and getting off a
thousand-pound animal, scooping up the droppings, putting them in a
bag and remounting on the trail. That's a serious public safety
issue."

The two sides may collide during the Jan. 20 hearing at City Hall to
consider Skidmore's appeal of her fine.

"We're going to make this a test case," Anderson said. "If the city
wants to make it an issue, we'll go to the wall on it."

ONCE AGAIN, PLEASE LET THE CITY OF NEWPORT BEACH KNOW HOW RIDICULOUS
THEIR LAW IS!!!!! TODAY IT IS A CITY IN SO. CALIFORNIA - TOMORROW IT
MAY BE YOUR CITY!!!!


CITY MANAGER HOMER BLUDAU
EMAIL: hbludau@xxxx
PHONE: 949-644-3000

ASSISTANT CITY MANAGER DAVID KIFF
PHONE: 949-644-3002





Here is a letter written to Newport Beach by one of my friends in
Bonsall to the council.


I cannot believe you are going to make horse-riders dismount from
their horses, to pick up manure while they are riding the Back Bay
Trails.     Since Back Bay is a sanctuary, or was, when we lived
nearby to there, natural horse excrement should actually be of benefit
to the soil.

As was reported in the L.A. Times, horses do not eat any kind of
meat...... only hay, grass & nutrients ......therefore the manure
which they produce is not offensive in odor..... I do not see what it
is that is bugging the non-equestrian homeowners, as they must have
known when they moved there, that there were going to be horses using
the trails, and possible manure as a result.

Horses do not often poop when they are ridden  -   they mostly do this
when they get a sudden fright, or if  "it is time", but most horses
refrain from doing this away from their homes, so there must be very
little manure of which to speak.

This seems to me to be a totally frivolous subject, and I think that
anyone who is objecting to the equestrian riders and their steeds'
normal gastro-intestinal functions, is in need of some psychiatric
therapy, or a hard-working job, as they obviously have too much time
on their hands to let others enjoy life.

Fiona Kennelly


Visit the Corral 20 web site: http://corral20.kc6hur.net
Visit the ETI Natioanl web site: http://www.eti.av.org
ite: http://corral20.kc6hur.net
Visit the ETI Natioanl web site: http://www.eti.av.org






=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Ridecamp is a service of Endurance Net, http://www.endurance.net.
Information, Policy, Disclaimer: http://www.endurance.net/Ridecamp
Subscribe/Unsubscribe http://www.endurance.net/ridecamp/logon.asp

Ride Long and Ride Safe!!

=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=