<% appTitle="Ridecamp Archives" %> Ridecamp: Re: [RC] Whoops, sent it before I was done....sorry
Ridecamp@Endurance.Net

[Archives Index]   [Date Index]   [Thread Index]   [Author Index]   [Subject Index]
Current to Wed Jul 23 17:38:20 GMT 2003
  • Next by Date: Re: [RC] sheath swelling/cleaning
  • - Heidi Smith
  • Prev by Date: Re: [RC] Sweat, Conditioning and -40 C Weather...
  • - Ed and Wendy Hauser

    Re: [RC] Whoops, sent it before I was done....sorry - Heidi Smith


    >I still have not seen any concrete evidence that horseback riding - THAT far and THAT long over a long period of time - doesn't hurt the growing bones.  I can't imagine that it wouldn't - especially since we're being told, quite firmly, how damaging too much too soon does to our horses. 
     
    Our young horses would be subjected to direct, concussive forces.  Riders do not undergo ANY kind of similar concussive forces--the motion of riding, if done in a relaxed fashion (and I've yet to see children riding long distance doing otherwise), is a passive sort of repetitive motion that never loads the joints, bones, or soft tissue supportive structures (ligaments, tendons) the way that direct concussive forces do. 
     
    >Any pediatric or orthopedic professionals out there that can give an opinion (not vet, totally different animal there). 
     
    Bone is bone, and concussion is concussion.  If we made these kids get out and RUN, you could compare.  (BTW, why is it that you compare young riders to young horses in one paragraph, and then say "totally different animal" in the next paragraph, and try to suggest that vets wouldn't have any way of comparing the two?  Actually, the tissues discussed here are more similar from species to species than is the sort of activity being compared.)
     
    >So far, all we've heard is hearsay and personal experience.  Neither is very scientific.  
     
    No, this isn't exactly a double-blind scientific study.  But so far, we've heard personally from folks who rode hard at a young age, and from people who've been closely associated with now-grown-up riders who rode hard at a young age, and the only now-adult who has complained of damage from riding was doing something other than distance riding.  The many hours I put in riding for cattle between the ages of 5 and 8 didn't hurt me a bit, but it sure taught me a lot.
     
    Heidi

    Replies
    Re: [RC] Whoops, sent it before I was done....sorry, Rae Callaway