I have a 1997 Sundowner 2 horse straightload gooseneck.  We purchased 
it new, and have been very happy with it - it is all steel, though, their 
Charter model.
I have the door from the dressing room to the horse compartment, and would 
highly recommend that to anyone.  It has made life quite a bit easier when 
I've been camping in the rain - the extra space really helps.  I also set 
up my shower in the horse compartment.  I love the layout and my 
setup.  The only thing I would order differently, if I were to do it all 
over again, is to get an extra foot or two in the dressing room.  I'm not 
desperate for the space, but it would make it a bit more convenient.  I 
have the camper door, but could live without it.
We don't have Four Star dealer in our area.  When shopping though, we 
did carefully look at a slightly used four star.   It wasn't the 
layout that I wanted, but was a very solid well made all aluminum trailer.
  the deal breakers.....
  Sundowner vs Four Star...hubby wishywashy
  Sundowner is 15,800 
  valuelite 
  wieghs 4740 lbs
  10 yr warranty 
  better financing
  will install my towing for free.(helped me)
  does not have the 7000 lb axels has 5200 axels
  does not have 16 inch wheels htey are 15 inch
  YES MY TRUCK WILL PULL IT VERY SAFELY WITH EXTRA TO 
SPARE!!!!!!!!!!!
  I contacted Dodge, Sundowner and several trusted automotive places and 
  was told it would.
  Read the owners manual 10,000 load max I will have approx 6000 load 
  max
   
  Four Star
  15,300 
  400 to add my towing package
  7000 lb axles
  16 inch wheels
  same options as the listed sundowner except
  no sprayed floor liner
  no pass thru door
  this one weighs 4800 lbs
  rear tack is not colapsible
   
  We have searched and searched and SEARCHED for a ratings guide on the 
  internet and well... seems the best ratings guide out there is you 
folks!
  We went to both lots and poked proded asked questions and asked questions 
  till we were nearly thrown out (seems people don't like you asking 
  questions!)
  I want the sundowner 
  he is leaning to the four star! 
  I have only heard from one Sundowner and plenty of Featherlites but the 
  featherlites would Sooner have a 
  Fourstar...arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrggggggggggggggghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
  Happy Campers....helppppppppp somme moooooooreeeeeeeeeee!
  Carla (dang....gotta go to work...)
  Ansata (treat me treat me....)
  Haley (mee toooooo!)
  Rob "four Star" Lawson
   
   
  
  Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com
  =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= 
  Ridecamp is a service of Endurance Net, http://www.endurance.net. Information, 
  Policy, Disclaimer: http://www.endurance.net/RideCamp 
  =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=